Are the wine country fires a black swan?

Bella Oaks Vineyard in the fall with red canopy on green grass

“Of course there can always be a black swan event.”

A few months ago, I was speaking with a business owner who was thinking of selling his wine company. He asked the perennial question: “Is this a good time to sell?” Among my responses regarding the strength of his brand, the sustained growth and optimism in the wine industry as positive factors, I included one caveat: “Of course, there can always be a black swan event.”

From Wikipedia: “The black swan theory of events is a metaphor that describes an event that comes as a surprise, has a major effect, and is often inappropriately rationalized after the fact with the benefit of hindsight.”

The wine country fires that have ravaged the North Coast wine region are certainly a “surprise”.  Will they have a major effect on the winery M&A market? The short answer is that it’s too soon to tell, but here are some changes that I’ve seen as an advisor active in the market:

  • A Napa Valley Winery owner cancelled a planned site visit scheduled for October 13th to see a property he was considering acquiring. His winery was under threat and he was evacuating his family. The site visit has not yet been re-scheduled.
  • During the first week of the fires, and even through to the second week, deal closings came to a standstill.  In part because the lawyers involved in the contract negotiations had been evacuated.
  • The region and the industry really are in shock.  If you didn’t lose a home, you know someone who did. The lingering effects of this trauma are unknowable, but certain to be there.
  • Grape/wine supply scarcity was already a growing issue. Although the damage to vineyards and to wines was likely minimal in relation to actual production, markets are highly sensitive to perceptions.
  • And finally… the vulture capital investors have shown up. I recently heard from an investor that hadn’t contacted me since the ’08/’09/’10 market.

My hunch is that these fires will accelerate trends that were already present in the market, rather than dramatically changing the market.

M&A activity in the wine space had already decelerated, mostly driven by buyer management capacity limitations (they’ve bought a lot and need to absorb the acquisitions they already have). That will likely continue, with a return to a “normal” from a “hot” market. Grape scarcity was already an issue. With this event it is certain that brands without either contracted grape and/or wine supply or flexible future sourcing options are likely to struggle to find a buyer.

On the other hand, while transactions that were well on their way to completion will be wrapped up in the next few months, there will likely be a pause in the launch of new selling efforts. I, for one, am advising my clients to sit tight until January. 

Discover More

Wine business insights from Global Wine Partners

Ready to discuss your wine business?

Talk with our team about selling, buying, or valuing a wine business.